Epic decision portends new balance for reopening dunes in Glamis

Jeep on dune in GlamisSAN FRANCISCO, CA - Recreational visitors observing a fine flaky substance this morning at the Imperial Sand Dunes Recreation Area (ISDRA) will be pleased to hear it is not snow but judicial manna. Barely a month following argument, U.S. District Judge Susan Illston of the U.S. Northern District Court of California yesterday issued a long-awaited decision on the 2013 ISDRA management plan, ruling almost entirely on the side of the Bureau of Land Management, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, and sand-rider organizations, and against the latest challenge led by the Center for Biological Diversity. The ruling sets the stage for implementation of the 2013 plan, which would allow resumption of access to areas placed off-limits to riders through “interim” closures imposed over a decade ago.

The litigation over riding at the ISDRA began in 2000, and has resulted in multiple trips to Judge Illston’s courtroom where BLM, USFWS, and recreation enthusiasts have suffered multiple setbacks. The 2013 plan followed lengthy public input and was designed in response to the Court’s 2006 ruling and new critical habitat designation by the USFWS for the Peirson’s milk-vetch (PMV), the plant species of primary concern at the Dunes. Preservationist plaintiffs raised an array of challenges under the Endangered Species Act and other laws to the new plan, but yesterday’s decision rejected those claims and upheld BLM’s plan, with the limited exception of finding that a recovery plan for the PMV is overdue and must be issued by 2019 unless the USFWS makes a specific finding that a recovery plan will not promote conservation of the species.

A copy of yesterday’s decision can be viewed at this link.

“I have shed tears upon nearly every announcement of the Court, but this time they are tears of joy,” said Jim Bramham, who holds leadership positions with several of the recreationist organizations, including the American Sand Association and California Association of 4 Wheel Drive Clubs. “Our work will never be finished, but this vindicates our long-running, expensive and sometimes controversial team effort to restore balance to ISDRA management,” Bramham added.

The ISDRA, popularly known by many as “Glamis” for the small town within its boundaries, is located near the southern U.S. border in Imperial County, California, and spans roughly 167,000 acres. There is a broad range of management prescriptions covering the area, and over 26,000 acres have been formally designated as Wilderness, where no vehicle access is allowed. The 2013 plan would continue vehicle closures in PMV critical habitat, and allow some form of riding on about 127,000 acres. The Dunes are a prized destination for sand-riding enthusiasts throughout the country, and over 1,000,000 of them visit the area in a typical year.

The rider groups intervening in the case to assist in defense of the BLM plan included the American Sand Association, San Diego Off-Road Coalition, Off-Road Business Association, American Motorcyclist Association District 37, California Association of 4 Wheel Drive Clubs, BlueRibbon Coalition, Desert Vipers, California Off-Road Vehicle Association, and High Desert Multiple Use Coalition, with funding and strategic support from EcoLogic Partners. The intervener groups were represented by David Hubbard of Carlsbad, Paul Turcke of Boise, Idaho, and Dennis Porter of Sacramento.

Coming Up

JUL
24

07.24.2014 - 07.27.2014
Jeepers Jamboree

JUL
26

07.26.2014 - 07.27.2014
Jeep Beach West

JUL
26

07.26.2014 10:00 - 15:00
CA4WDC Central District Meeting

AUG
7

08.07.2014 - 08.10.2014
Sierra Trek

AUG
7

08.07.2014 - 08.10.2014
Jeep Jamboree

Win a brand new Jeep built by MetalCloak

Subscribe to enews and access alerts

Register online for Sierra Trek

Gold Sponsors

Search

Join CA4WDC
Donate to Cal4Wheel

Latest News

  • Spotting 101: Good spotting makes a difference +

    A friend sent me a quick note asking if there are universal hand signals for the spotters. Every spotter may Read More
  • Jo Snyder is new North District VP +

    Jo Snyder was elected as the new North District VP at yesterday's North District meeting. She will serve the remainder Read More
  • Send us your pics +

    We just introduced a new Poser Page in the In Gear and online where you can show off your rigs. Read More
  • Bramham writes his last report +

    It is with a wide range of emotion that I write what will be my last report as your NRC. Read More
  • 1

ingear-cover-june-14

Get free Win-A-Jeep tickets for multi-year renewals

Corporate & Associate Sponsors

  • 4wheel-parts logo
  • Advance Adapters logo
  • BF Goodrich logo
  • Extreme Terrain
  • metalcloak
  • Poison Spyder logo
  • warn
  • xventure-color-dar
  • Currie Enterprises logo
  • Fox Racing Shox logo
  • Rigid Industries logo
  • AEV logo
  • ARB logo
  • Daystar logo
  • Factor 55 logo
  • JE Reel logo
  • Magnaflow Performance Exhaust logo
  • calif-casuals
  • Lasher's logo
  • TrailGear logo
  • Tuffy Security Products logo
  • West Coast Differentials logo
  • Tom-Woods Custom-Drive-Shafts-Logo
  • Yukon Gear & Axle logo
  • bas-offroad
  • everything-radios
  • fhp-automotive-50
  • Fountain Valley Tire
  • FunTreks Guidebooks Inc.
  • Jeeperformance Inc.
  • LandOps logo
  • rugged-rocks-50
  • sneveys-offroad
  • sPod